Chicago Cubs manager Craig Counsell has reignited his public criticism of Major League Baseball’s two-way player rule, commonly known as the “Ohtani Rule.”
Counsell’s Frustration with Two-Way Player Restrictions
On April 25 (KST), during a series against the LA Dodgers, Dodgers manager Dave Roberts described the current standings as “expected” but made no effort to conceal his irritation over the situation.
The Ohtani Rule governs players who pitch and hit, requiring a pitcher to log at least 20 innings in the majors in a season. To qualify as a position player in the same year, they must also appear in 20 games at a defensive position, delivering a minimum of three plate appearances per game. Only then can they secure eligibility, often at the expense of at least three at-bats per contest from designated hitters.
Analysis reveals this standard, reinforced in 2020, directly impacts teams like the Dodgers managing elite two-way talents such as Shohei Ohtani.
The Cubs, grappling with early-season injuries and limited roster flexibility, face operational challenges. Counsell addressed the rule’s implications head-on, stating, “To me, this rule aims to promote international competition.” He added, “Only a team with a truly special player can enjoy those benefits—it’s the most expected outcome. Rules targeting one team are my motto.”
Roberts Counters with Strong Defense
In response, Dodgers skipper Dave Roberts issued a pointed rebuttal. “There’s a reason that player receives protection,” Roberts said. “Any team safeguarding a player like Ohtani can claim the same advantages. Exposing such talent is each team’s choice.”
He emphasized, “Ohtani stands out as a special player everyone anticipates seeing.”
Counsell clarified his stance, insisting it targets no specific club. “This isn’t about the Dodgers or Ohtani—it’s the rule itself,” he explained.
Roberts anticipates potential discipline from the exchange but noted no plans to bench Ohtani in the ongoing series.
