Toronto Blue Jays may deploy newly signed starter Cody Ponce in the bullpen during the second half of the season, according to expert analysis.
Analyst Predicts Flexible Role
Analysts forecast that while the Blue Jays intend to use Ponce as a full-time starter, circumstances could lead to a bullpen assignment later in the year. Eric Lau noted, “Toronto plans to employ Ponce as a full-time starter, but if a strong pitcher joins the rotation—like situations with Eric Lauer last year—there is significant potential to shift him to relief duties in the second half.” Projections align quantitatively, estimating 24 starts and 23 relief appearances across 47 games, totaling 162 innings with a 3.90 ERA and 2.5 fWAR.
Contract Matches Innings Potential
The Blue Jays secured Ponce on a $30 million deal, calibrated to his seasonal workload. Expectations run high for rotation contributions, but limited prior big-league volume raises questions about full-season starter viability. MLB.com echoes similar views, ranking Ponce as a No. 4 or 5 starter behind ace Dylan Cease, Kevin Gausman, and Trey Yesavage.
Career Stats and Injury Risks
Ponce demonstrated promise in limited starts last season. However, his major league innings remain modest: a pro debut of 68 1/3 innings in 2023 followed by a career-high 127 innings in 2024. Concerns persist over workload capacity and recovery, especially compared to KBO stars who faltered in MLB transitions despite domestic MVP honors.
Alternative Rotation Options
Toronto holds flexibility with injured returnees, re-signing candidates, and trade possibilities like Max Scherzer types. Ponce’s minor-league depth provides a safety net, but failing to secure rotation experience could prompt a positional change or trade. The team views the $30 million investment as justification for high-impact deployment, whether starting or relieving, to maximize long-term value.
